Liquid Ring, Dry Claw or Rotary Vane: Which Vacuum Pump Fits?
Liquid ring pumps are the most tolerant of wet, condensing or particle-laden gas. Lubricated rotary vane pumps are efficient on relatively clean, dry gas. Dry claw pumps are chosen when the process must stay oil-free with minimal maintenance.
Three technologies, three characters
A liquid ring pump uses a rotating ring of liquid, usually water, as the seal. Water vapour and some particles are therefore not a problem.
A rotary vane pump uses vanes sliding in a rotor, with oil as lubricant and seal. It is efficient and reaches deep vacuum on clean gas.
A dry claw pump uses two claw-shaped rotors that turn without touching and without oil in the compression chamber.
Quick comparison
| Aspect | Liquid ring | Lubricated rotary vane | Dry claw |
|---|---|---|---|
| Wet gas/condensate | Very tolerant | Not ideal | Limited |
| Oil contact with process | None (uses liquid) | Yes | None |
| Water use | Yes | No | No |
| Routine maintenance | Liquid and seals | Oil and filter changes | Low |
Typical applications
- Paper, sugar and chemical plants with wet gas: Azmec liquid ring pumps up to 38,500 m³/h, with ATEX and API 681 versions.
- Deep or oil-free vacuum: PVR Vacuum Design offers rotary vane, dry claw, Roots and screw down to 0.02 mbar abs.
- Vacuum and air for handling and packaging: Ivaco and Mapro side channel blowers, lobe blowers and vacuum pumps.
Data to prepare
- Gas or vapour being pumped, including water and dust content
- Flow in m³/h and target vacuum level
- Daily operating hours and standby needs
- Whether the area is an ATEX zone
Frequently asked questions
Do liquid ring vacuum pumps use a lot of water?
They do use a working liquid. Consumption can be cut with partial or total recovery systems, depending on liquid temperature and capacity.
When is an ATEX version needed?
When the pumped gas or the installation area can form an explosive atmosphere, for example with solvents in chemical and pharma plants.
Can I replace my old pump with a different technology?
Yes, as long as the process data is known. Send gas data, flow, vacuum and a photo of the old nameplate and the Certechs team will match it.
Need Technical Equipment Consultation?
Discuss operational requirements, flow rates, capacities, and site layout directly with Certechs engineering specialists.